|

Fractional Interest Ownership
- Passive Income
Tenant in common (TIC) investments
Ownership in a TIC has opened up a
whole world of institutional-grade properties to
investors, and it is changing the face of passive
real estate ownership!
While not new,
Tenants-In-Common (TIC) commercial real estate has become a very popular
way to invest, and a powerful way to handle a 1031
exchange. However, TICs are not for everyone.
As a Tenant-in-Common, you own a piece
of a larger, Class-A, professionally-managed
property (usually larger than you would be able to
purchase alone), you receive a pro-rata share of
all revenues generated by the property, you
benefit from tax shelters, and you preserve your
capital by investing in property that should continue to
appreciate. You obtain, in almost all cases,
non-recourse financing which has been placed on
the property.
It is important to understand
several facts about TICs:
-
Each
owner in a TIC receives an individual deed for
his percentage interest in the entire property.
Investors are individual owners, not limited
partners.
-
Each owner has the same rights
as would a single owner.
-
In March 2002, the IRS released
Revenue Procedure 2002-22, which set forth the
conditions and guidelines that allow a small
group of single owners to invest into larger
real estate projects. This cleared the way for
1031 exchanges into TIC properties.
-
Most TICs are sold as a security,
since it is deemed to be an 'investment
contract'. However, there are some options
for real estate-based TICs as well.
TICs are sold as either
real-estate based or as securities-based
investments. The US Supreme Court, in the Howey
Decision, determined that an investment contract
is included in the definition of a security.
They defined an investment contract as
1) an investment of money 2) into a
common enterprise 3) with the expectation of
profits 4) derived primarily from the effort of
others.
Hence, many sponsors believe that TICs are
securities. Those offered as securities must
follow strict regulations and disclosure. An attorney opinion letter(s) should always be available regardless if
the property is sold as real estate-based or
securities-based, regarding qualification for the
1031 exchange.
Important to note:
Securities-based TICs only allow accredited
investors (defined as at least a $1M net worth, or specific
salary income of $200,000 for the last 2 years,
etc.).
Further, investors into securities-based TICs must
discuss their full financial picture with their
representative, because 'suitability' is an
important issue through SEC regulation.
TICs sold as real estate do not follow the same
regulations as they are regulated by the real
estate licensing entity (versus the securities
entity), but most of the reputable sponsors do
have similar formats. Full disclosure
including risk is not required in real estate to
the same extent as securities, but a full due
diligence is part of the acquisition.
Whether an investor considers a securities or
real-estate TIC, the information below is relevant.
Why are TICs popular
for 1031 Exchanges?
Any investor who wants
to trade into a management-free, NNN (triple net)
single ownership
property knows that product supply is low and
competition is fierce, and there is a huge amount
of legwork just to obtain a property. Those who
do manage to tie up a property with a Letter of
Intent in proper time to identify (45 days from
sale of relinquished property by the IRS rule) need to negotiate
the contract, conduct the due diligence, and arrange
financing. Sometimes one cannot successfully negotiate
the contract to satisfaction, sometimes facts
come out in due diligence that show you do not
want the property, and sometimes the financing
becomes difficult to arrange - or a commitment
can't be obtained before the end of the financing
contingency (if the Seller even allowed one).
TIC sponsors have carefully
conducted their selection and extensive due diligence process
when they purchased or tied up the property (which
is provided to you), they have arranged the financing
with excellent terms (and it is the desirable
non-recourse financing), and they have done all
the work that you the investor would have to do.
Investors and their team (attorney, accountant,
etc.) can review the due diligence information in appropriate
time frames for the trade. Investors can 'slide' into properties with little
fuss, and meet all of the deadlines required by
the IRS in time.
Another more obvious reason
why TICs are popular with the 'smaller' investor
is that the investor is able to buy into
institutional-grade properties they could not buy
on their own, especially management-free
credit-tenant
real estate that would be too expensive or out of
reach to them.
Some 'larger' investors like
TICs because they can spread their investments
into a number of properties and diversify the portfolio,
much like their stock portfolio, and in addition
they can complete the 1031 exchange within the
time limits.
**************************************************************************************
TICs are popular
because they are simpler to acquire than many
types of properties (many of the
same reasons as sited above), can be
conservative and straight-forward, and the
returns are generally projected and estimated. Cash
flow is not guaranteed and can fluctuate, but the
Proforma reports and projections help the investor
to know the studied scenario based on tenants,
leases, expenses and such. No
management, no fuss, no tenant problems - this is appealing to more
and more people. The investor
is also able to diversify - for instance, some
funds into a Class A office building, some funds in
a Class A apartment complex, and some into a prime
retail
powercenter.
**************************************************************************************
It
is important to understand the TIC sponsors, their
track record and background. (The
sponsor is the company that brings the product to
market for sale). It is also
important to understand details about the property
itself - the real estate fundamentals - and the
financing. There are many details that make
one investment stronger than another. Legacy
assists you in every step.
TICs
Legacy
Real Estate & Investments studies the TIC sponsors
(and they are growing each quarter) and only
refers or suggests offerings by reputable TIC sponsors to
assist investors with the best possible choices:
Class
A Office Buildings with credit or national tenants
Large Apartment Complexes in appreciating areas
Retail, both single tenant and shopping centers
New Assisted Living Facilities
Other specialized property types, including
industrial
-
Some
of the sponsored properties have long term NNN
(triple-net) leases or Master NNN Leases in place,
usually with annual increases to the Tenants in
common. This offers known
returns to the investor. However, it does
cap potentially higher returns and there are some
inherent weaknesses to a Master lease.
Sophisticated investors often prefer a proforma
type of approach, so the upside isn't capped.
Legacy can explain further if interested.
-
TIC
offerings have the most
advantageous non-recourse (no personal guarantee
required from the investor)
financing, although an all-cash TIC is
available through one retail sponsor, and from
time to time other sponsors will offer this.
Legacy does not recommend investing in a TIC with
interest-only loans. (Many sponsors may have
1 or 2 years of interest-only, which can work if
the real estate fundamentals and entire offering
make sense).
-
Sponsors
provide the entire due diligence packet
to the
prospective investor and handle the financing
placement and Closing procedures, as well as
providing annual tax forms and reporting on the property
to the investors.
Several TIC
properties
can hold IRA funds with monthly cashflow. Others have mortgaged-backed notes that
pay a nice return - some may be used for your IRA
as well.
There are many steps to
reviewing the offerings. Investors need to study very carefully the Proforma,
the overall strategy, and take special attention
with areas as Reserves, Insurance coverage, and
conservative Income projections. The
structure of the offering, the attorney opinion,
and many other details will be reviewed for each
offering. We must remember that there are no guarantees on
anything, and there are always risks to investment.
Summary - Advantages
of TIC ownership:
- Low Minimum Investment
for any Investor.
$100,000 to $350,000 minimum for some TIC investments (this
varies by property and has been rising);
$250,000 to $450,000 is now more common as a minimum, though
some offerings could have a minimum as high a
$1M to $1.5M.
- Flexibility for
the 1031 Exchange. By identifying a TIC
property as one of the replacement choices,
the taxpayers entire proceeds can be applied
to the TIC if the other choices fall through
as it can be a sure thing;
or the taxpayer decides to place all proceeds into
the TIC or TICs as a first choice; or the taxpayer can invest
the 'spill-over' monies into the TIC.
- Decreased
1031 Risk. If a deal
collapses among other properties identified for
a 1031, the TIC is ready to take all proceeds.
Investors can choose properties in which the TIC
sponsor has already closed and owns the
property, thereby taking away a 1031 closing
risk.
- Speed and Simplicity.
By eliminating the loan shopping process,
the time expended to search for a loan, to
negotiate, handle due diligence and appraisal
work, etc. can be avoided or at the least
handled in shorter time frames.
- Diversification.
In a typical 1031 exchange, the taxpayer will
identify 3 potential replacement properties
and subsequently purchase only 1. TIC equity ownership
makes it feasible to identify and acquire ownership
in 3 properties, thereby increasing
diversification (the investor can also choose 3
different property types, such as a retail
building, an office building, and an assisted
living facility, for example.) Partial
ownership in properties in different geographic
areas can bring even greater stability to a
portfolio.
Summary -
Disdvantages
of TIC ownership:
-
There is no developed secondary market for TICs.
The investments are to be long-term holds (2
years to 10 years or more, depending on the
property) so you should never invest monies that
you think you would need. While you can
sell a TIC share, it could take some time and
there are unknowns.
-
Real estate is illiquid by nature.
Related to the first point, remember than real
estate is not liquid. You can't decide to
sell today and have the cash tomorrow.
- You
will not be in management control. A
professional management team will handle your
asset. While this can be an advantage, for
some people it can be seen as a disadvantage -
that is, loss of control.
- You
cannot refinance your portion. There
will be non-recourse financing on the TIC
building, which you will 'assume'.
- You
will own a property with other people, unknown
to you. Certain decisions will require
a vote or consensus and there is some risk here.
- In
any investment, including a TIC, you could lose
your money. Review your situation and the
investment carefully before investing.
Kathy
Heshelow is the author of the newly published
book, EFFORTLESS CASH FLOW: the ABCs of TICs
(TENANT IN COMMON PROPERTIES), an educational
book for investors and advisors. (www.ticbook.com)
Kathy has a number
of information and educational sheets on various
stages of the investment
to help those who are
working through the process exclusively with
Legacy. An important sheet is "Preparing
for the TIC investment", which gives you a
checklist of what you should be doing now.
Final Word
- It
is important to understand that there are risks in
any investment. It is important to
understand the Pros and Cons of TIC investing.
Please discuss this fully with Kathy Heshelow.
This is neither an offer to sell nor a
solicitation to buy a security. Such an offer can
only be made by means of a Private Placement
Memorandum.
Contact Legacy
to discuss this today, and ask for the emailable information sheets with more
details on TICs. Get educated about issues
through radio interviews at
www.ticbook.com/media.html
Legacy Real Estate & Investments,
Inc. and CapWest Securities, Inc. are not
affiliated companies.
Securities
offered through CapWest Securities, Inc.
Member FINRA (former NASD), SIPC, MSRB
3900 S. Wadsworth Blvd., Suite 590, Lakewood, CO
80235
Tel: 303.798.5407
Member:
This logo is
a registered trademark of the Tenant-in-Common
Association.
|